An open letter to the “Yes Maccas” proponents

To the Yes Maccas folks:

“If you don’t like Maccas, just don’t eat there.”

So say those who favor a McDonalds in Tecoma. But, is that really the issue? Do you suppoose that we’re afraid Ronald and his minions are going to come storming into our homes and force that McCrap down our throats? Of course not. It’s a correct answer, so it sounds reasonable. The un-asked question, however, makes it absurd.

The “why” of not wanting a Maccas isn’t really relevant. The fact is, we, the residents of Tecoma — and more generally, the Dandenong Ranges — simply don’t want one here, for whatever reason. And we, being residents here, owning property here, having a real vested interest here, as a community have a right to determine the character and composition of OUR community. We have MORE of a right to that than ANY individual or business has to say otherwise. This is especially true of a business that doesn’t currently exist there. We have spoken, in a voice that is loud and clear. We don’t want a Maccas here. Period.

That voice was not only ignored, it was silenced not by reason, but by corporate money and greed. McDonalds is only the latest example of an ongoing effort on the part of large, monied interests to neutralize the obstacles that stand between them and making ever more money — at our expense.

Those who wanted a Maccas in Tecoma had just as much time and opportunity to respond in favor of it as the more than 1,100 of us who filed objections to it. The council meeting during which the permit was unanimously voted down was attended by over 600 of us who objected; I counted no more than a dozen — and I’m being generous — in favor of it.

The council vote should have been the end of the story. Instead, Maccas sued in VCAT, not JUST to build in Tecoma, but … and here’s the really important part, folks … to show that they could nullify the will of the people, that they could silence our voices, to show that they were indifferent to, even spiteful of the quality of life we want in the Hills. To show that Democracy itself is
irrelevant to them and to anyone, any corporation with enough money. Why, again, is irrelevant. It’s simply what corporations do: they make money, as much of it as they can.

The voice of the community — thousands of us — was clearly heard by the council, and they responded appropriately in denying Maccas the permt to build in Tecoma. You had a voice, too. It wasn’t nearlly so loud. But you threw in with the folks with the big money, and, as they say, money talks. It talks, it shouts, and, in this case, it drowned out the voice of the clear majority of people. You may think that this went in your favor. Ultimately, it will not. Today you, who favor a Maccas in Tecoma, think that you’re on the “winning” side of this issue. I suspect that, before long, You will see that we all lost on this one, all of us. The voice you thought was yours was simply the Money talking — you were just mouthing the words for it. One day, soon, you will find your rights trampled, your voice silenced.

You don’t like having your rights trampled, don’t like being told to shut up?

Just give up your rights, and don’t say a thing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *